UN’s refugee body confirms talks with Israeli and foreign governments on a deal that would enable some asylum seekers to stay in Israel permanently, resettle others
Israel is in negotiations with the United Nations High Commission on Refugees to resettle a portion of African asylum seekers in third countries deemed by the UN to be “safe,” possibly including Western countries, in exchange for some of the refugees to be given permanent residency in Israel.
The deal would likely halt Israel’s current campaign to deport thousands of asylum seekers to African countries, widely believed to be Rwanda and Uganda.
She declined to name the countries interested in absorbing the refugees or what percentage of the refugees would be able to stay in Israel. Since 2013, the UNHCR, working with a number of different countries, has resettled 2,400 asylum seekers in third countries which they consider safe, including the US and Canada.
Harel said was confident that an agreement could offer a viable solution for the approximately 38,000 African asylum seekers currently in Israel. “We would see such an arrangement as a win-win for the refugees as well as the State of Israel,” said Harel.
The Prime Minister’s Office refused multiple requests for comment.
The UNHCR, as well as a number of human rights organizations have expressed dismay with Israel’s program of deporting asylum seekers to third countries, which were officially unnamed. Reports have named Rwanda and Uganda, which are listed by the UN as “areas of concern.”
“Due to the secrecy surrounding this policy and the lack of transparency concerning its implementation, it has been very difficult for UNHCR to follow up and systematically monitor the situation of people relocated to these African countries,” the UNHCR said in a statement in November. “UNHCR, however, is concerned that these persons have not found adequate safety or a durable solution to their plight and that many have subsequently attempted dangerous onward movements within Africa or to Europe.”
Israel has deported approximately 4,000 asylum seekers to Rwanda and Uganda since December 2013, when the deportation program started.
A new law shuttering a holding facility and forcing asylum seekers to leave or go to jail has seen Israel kick off a fresh deportation campaign this week. Israel began handing out deportation notices to asylum seekers renewing their two-month visa on Sunday.
According to reports, the government hopes to deport 600 asylum seekers per month for the first year. People with open asylum applications cannot be deported before the applications are resolved.
On Monday, Netanyahu slammed international criticism of the handling of the asylum seeker situation as “a campaign of lies.”
“International law places obligations on countries and it also gives them rights. There is an obligation to accept refugees, and we accept refugees,” he said, “but international law also gives the right to a country to remove from its borders illegal migrants. We have no obligation to allow illegal labor migrants who are not refugees to remain here.”
Netanyahu also claimed that George Soros was funding protests against the deportations, a claim that Soros quickly denied.
Thousands of asylum seekers protested on Wednesday in front of the Rwandan embassy, part of a number of protests against the deportation in front of at least ten Rwandan embassies and consulates around the world. Protesters carried signs reading, “We will not fall into despair, we will stop this deportation,” “Recognizing refugees is a moral requirement,” “We don’t believe the racists,” and “Kagame — We’re not for sale.”
Eritrean activists have said that they believe around 20 deported asylum seekers have lost their lives in dangerous attempts to reach Europe.
Deportees to Rwanda have told The Times of Israel, and it has been widely reported in foreign media, that they are kept for a few days in a private home and then taken to the border with South Sudan or Uganda in the middle of the night. They are told to cross without documents, and to request asylum seeker status in the new country when they cross the border.
CONTINUE
This is packaged like some great deal for Israel. Buyer beware. UNHCR will help, fund, and manage for you. We know where that will end.
To paraphrase Ronald Reagan’s nine most terrifying words in the English language: I’m from the UNHCR and I’m here to help.
UNHCR will determine who gets to stay. Like the refugees they send to Europe or to the US, 99% Muslim and really persecuted Christians are sent back to their hell-holes.
Also UNHCR will set quotas for Israel.
No thanks. Better Israel makes its own sovereign decisions.
@ Edgar G.:
Exactly right and exactly what our enemies want.
I don’t see it as a “win-win” for Israel. What I see is that dumping itinerant Africans who sneaked into the tiny country for economic reasons, and/or perhaps encouraged by anti-Israel NGOs. All it will do is saddle us with a large, unwanted group who will not, cannot assimilate or be absorbed, and spawn a lower class not acceptable to Israeli mores.
Because of the unusual, I could say unique Jewish makeup of the religion, race and people basically being one, (regardless of the comparatively few proselytes) a people different from any other, these illegal sneakers will become another kind of “Black Hebrews”…. who are basically a gradually growing curse on the Land that the Govts of the time were too cowardly to deport.