Blind hatred of Trump is sending some American Jews off the moral rails
By Melanie Phillips
President Donald Trump at Western Wall, Jerusalem, 2017
There is clearly no limit to the depths of moral perversity that the enemies of President Donald Trump are prepared to plumb, not least within America’s Jewish community.
The Jewish Democratic Council of America has released a new campaign ad aimed at Jewish voters in swing states which compares Trump’s presidency to the rise of fascism in Germany.
The ad features parallel images of antisemitism and nationalism in Nazi Germany and today’s America. There are images of antisemitic graffiti from 1930s Germany, along with similar attacks on a modern American synagogue and Jewish cemetery.
The narration states: “History shows us what happens when leaders use hatred and nationalism to divide their people.” The ad ends with a warning: “Hate does not stop itself. It must be stopped. VOTE.”
The council’s executive director, Halie Soifer, said: “A majority of American Jews feel less safe today than they did four years ago due to the rise of white nationalism and antisemitism under Donald Trump.”
“This, coupled with Trump’s assault on our democratic institutions, are [sic] reminiscent of the rise of fascism in 1930s Germany. President Trump’s use of hatred for political purposes has made America less safe for Jews and we are voting accordingly.”
Nor is this the only linkage of Trump with the Nazis. The Democratic presidential contender, Joe Biden, has likened him to the Nazi propagandist Joseph Goebbels.
All of this is appalling for two reasons.
First, it slanders and smears President Trump. Certainly, he is a divisive character; rather than bring people together, he prefers to pour petrol onto the cultural conflagration. One can legitimately object to failings in his personality and temperament, as well as things he has said or done.
What is unacceptable, however, is to suggest he is a fascist, a Nazi, an attacker of democratic institutions and has made America less safe for Jews. Each of those claims is untrue.
Whatever his flaws, Trump is at base an American patriot. He stands for upholding the constitution, the rule of law and American values against those who would destroy them.
He has tried to enforce immigration law and the concept of citizenship; the Democrats seek to undermine them. He stands against the violent, anti-white and anti-American agenda of Black Lives Matter and Antifa; the Democrats support and endorse it.
Understandably exercised by the carnage wrought by this agenda on numerous American cities over the past few months, Trump clearly dismisses marginal far-right white groups as not even worth thinking about.
As a result, he has allowed his enemies to paint him falsely as a supporter of white nationalism. This happened again in his first presidential debate this week with Joe Biden.
Asked whether he would denounce white nationalism, he said “Sure.” Pressed again to do so, he asked whom he was being asked to condemn. When Biden said the far-right extremist group “Proud Boys,” Trump replied, “Proud Boys, stand down and stand by.” He then repeated that the real problem was Antifa, and someone had to deal with them.
Afterwards, the president said he had no idea who Proud Boys were. It was obvious that he had been preoccupied instead with pointing out the left-wing violence of Antifa.
Trump’s unwise dismissal of what he considers unimportant has enabled his enemies once again to distort what happened in order to smear him.
The claim that he encourages the far-right rests on an infamous falsehood, peddled repeatedly by Biden and which features in the imagery of the new campaign ad.
This is that, after the 2017 protest in Charlottesville, Va., over confederate statues that turned violent after attracting neo-Nazis and other white supremacists, Trump praised “some very fine people on both sides.”
As his words made clear, “very fine people” referred specifically to the peaceful statue protesters. In the very next breath, he said: “I’m not talking about the neo-Nazis and the white nationalists, because they should be condemned totally.” Yet his words have been twisted to claim he was praising neo-Nazis.
To accuse him in addition of causing attacks on Jews is breathtakingly perverse. Trump has done more for the Jewish people than any previous American president.
Not only has he proved himself to be a staunch ally of Israel, but he has also taken unprecedented action to combat antisemitism. At the end of last year, he signed an executive order allowing funding to be withheld from antisemitic college or educational programmes.
Harvard Law professor emeritus Alan Dershowitz called this measure “a game-changer,” and said it was “one of the most important events in the 2,000-year battle against antisemitism.”
Jews are currently being attacked from the left, from the far-right and from Islamic radicals and their proxies on the streets. But it’s the Democrats who support Antifa and Black Lives Matter with their hateful anti-Jewish and anti-Israel agenda.
It’s the Democrats who have given rise to “The Squad” of congresswomen who vent anti-Israel or anti-Jewish bigotry. It’s the Democrats who happily associate themselves with the immensely influential former Nation of Islam leader Louis Farrakhan, who calls the Jews “satanic” and blood-suckers,” and claims that they have wrapped their “tentacles” around the US government.
If there’s one characteristic common to left-wing ideologies, it is hatred. Left-wing ideologues hate and try to destroy anyone who challenges their dogma.
Trump has been the victim of this hatred. It’s so strong that he has been subjected to an unprecedented three-year attempt to lever him out of office through an unsubstantiated smear campaign involving an abuse of due process by officials, the Democratic Party and the media.
Shocking as all this is, however, the second factor involved in this attack on Trump is worse. It is the use of Nazism as a casual smear.
It equates what Trump has done with the rise of Nazism. Since Trump is clearly not aiming to wipe out the Jews, nor create a totalitarian dictatorship, nor attempt the invasion and subjugation of the world, the conclusion must be that the Jewish Democratic Council of America is downgrading Nazism in order to make a below-the-belt partisan attack.
The ad speaks of stopping hatred. But as Ruth Wisse observes in her essay in National Interest, Nazism was not defined by hatred but was instead the organisation of politics against the Jews. “The politics of grievance and blame may indeed foment hatred, distrust, envy, rage, fear and violence, but it is primarily a political instrument for gaining, wielding, and extending power,” she writes.
So this ad misrepresents and trivialises the true evil of Nazism — in order to promote baseless hatred against an individual, not just to oppose but to destroy him.
Blinded by hatred of Trump, his enemies rush to paint him as a Nazi while evacuating actual Nazism of its meaning and turning it into an empty political smear. This is to betray the memory of all who were murdered in the Holocaust or who gave their lives in the war to stop Hitler.
And not only is Joe Biden guilty of this moral bankruptcy but the Jewish Democratic Council of America — and the wider community of liberal Jews who are silently nodding assent to this disgusting spectacle.
It’s not just the victims of the Shoah they are betraying here, but once again the core ethical values of Judaism itself.
@ Sebastien Zorn:
It WAS a fascist regime just like any other and it was extremely evil and oppressive to the Germans themselves PLUS it possessed a racial theory calling for extermination of Jews who had been viewed by most Germans and others as evil aliens and troublemakers LONG BEFORE Hitler and his Nazis came to power; this theory also included extermination or enslavement of other “Untermenschen” by the pure Arian race.
This racial theory was actually acquired by the Germans from the Great Britain and the United States who jointly prevented the European Jews from leaving Europe before the war knowing what was planned for them by Hitler.
To insist that Nazism is defined solely by its Jew hatred is to WHITEWASH IT and to deprive people of the knowledge necessary to recognize when Nazis are coming to power again (this time soft pedaling their antisemitism until the time is ripe – “stand back and stand by!”)
@ Reader:
No, trivializing is EXACTLY pretending that Jew hatred is NOT its defining feature. Otherwise, it was just a fascist regime like many others. Yes, it persecuted other groups but so did other fascist and totalitarian regimes. It was in its relentless and industrialized drive to totally exterminate every human being on the planet with Jewish grandparents that it was unique not to mention the level of dehumanization is unparallelled coupled with an almost successful drive for world conquest. To use Nazi instead of totalitarian or fascist for other purposes simply deprives the word of its sting. It’s like saying and antisemite is somebody who hates Arabs because Arabs are semites. It takes a word with emotionally weighted baggage out of our vocabulary. This is what antisemites intend, of course. The left goes after the dictionary first. Whoever controls the language, controls the narrrative. A Nazi is not someone who is prejudiced against Jews. A Nazi is someone who wants every Jewish man, woman, chlld and baby, as a race, on the grounds of race, to be exterminated from the face of the planet. Farakhan, the Black Israelites and Islamists talk like Nazis when they say Jews are descended from apes and pigs and are Satan or fake Jews and promote murder against us.
Trivializing Nazism is EXACTLY pretending that its defining feature is Jew hatred.
Nazism has plenty wrong with it in addition to its Jew hatred (which has never been limited to Nazis or to the so-called “far-right” or “”far-left”, or some “antisemites” who just need more information and education to stop being antisemites).
The way some people talk, you would think that if not for this unfortunate feature, nothing was really wrong with the Nazis.
After all, they were great patriots of Germany and fought with great determination against communism!
And Hitler raised the German economy in three years with his charisma!
The last one is a close quote from an American college humanities textbook.
And this is a real quote from President Trump:
“Real power is—I don’t even want to use the word—fear.”
Presidential candidate Donald J. Trump in an interview with Bob Woodward and Robert Costa on March 31, 2016, at the Old Post Office Pavilion, Trump International Hotel, Washington, D.C.
Reminds you of someone, doesn’t it?
I’m Jewish and I approve this message.