T. Belman. “Earmarked for a Palestinian state” by whom? Certainly not Israel. Israel does not hold these lands on trust for the Arabs yet the international community wants to force Israel to do just that.
The UNSC resolution in 1979 calling settlements illegal, was ultra vires the Charter of the UN and therefor has no validity. The purpose of the UN is to keep the peace and not to decide what is legal. Pres Reagan disagreed with this resolution and with Pres Carter and called the settlements “illegitimate” rather than illegal. There is a big difference.
During the second intafadah in 2001, Sen Mitchell visited Israel on a fact finding mission and he recommended that Israel stop settlement construction and the Arabs stop the violence, thus linking the two. The US put this recommendation in the Roadmap and ever since has tried to make it binding on Israel. Neither this recommendation nor the Roadmap is binding but the international community would have you believe that it is illegal for Israel to build settlements or that Israel is committed to refrain from building them. Neither is true.
Quartet’s calls to halt construction in East Jerusalem and West Bank ignored by Jerusalem, peace process coordinator says
Settlement construction has “surged” in the two months since the diplomatic Quartet called for a halt to the construction of Jewish outposts on Palestinian land, a UN envoy said Monday. His statement was rejected by an Israeli government spokesman.
In a much-awaited report, the Quartet — the United States, Russia, the European Union and the United Nations — had urged Israel to stop building settlements and called on the Palestinians to cease incitement to violence.
But Nickolay Mladenov, the UN coordinator for the Middle East peace process, acknowledged that the appeal had fallen on deaf ears.
“Its recommendations continue to be ignored, including by a surge in Israeli settlement-related announcements and continuing demolitions,” Mladenov told the Security Council.
The Quartet report was to serve as the basis for reviving the Israeli-Palestinian peace process, which has been comatose since a US initiative collapsed in April 2014.
The international community has been expressing growing alarm to the effect that the construction of Jewish settlements on land earmarked for a future Palestinian state is killing off prospects for a peace deal based on the two-state solution.
Since July 1, Israeli has advanced plans for over 1,000 housing units in East Jerusalem and 735 units in the West Bank, Mladenov said.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government is also seeking tenders for 323 units to expand east Jerusalem settlements and for 42 units in Kiryat Arba near Hebron, for which it is allocating $13 million in new funding.
Israel has undertaken a land survey on the outskirts of Bethlehem for the establishment of a new settlement in a move that would contribute to the “dismemberment of the southern West Bank,” said Mladenov, in an apparent reference to plans to expand Efrat to areas beyond the security fence.
Demolitions of Palestinian homes are on the rise in the West Bank, with over 130 structures destroyed, Mladenov said. He singled out the Bedouin communities east of Jerusalem and in Susiya in the southern West Bank, warning that “the demolition of this community would set a dangerous precedent for displacement.”
Netanyahu has repeatedly rejected calls for a halt to settlement expansion, arguing that the residential projects are not an obstacle to peace. BUT HE HAS IMPOSED A FREEZE NEVERTHELESS.
The Security Council declared Israeli neighborhoods in East Jerusalem and settlements in the West Bank to be illegal in a resolution adopted in 1979. Israel considers East Jerusalem part of its capital, and says the status of the West Bank must be resolved in bilateral peace talks.
Mladenov said that determination was “equally true and even more urgent a concern today.”
A spokesman for Netanyahu rejected the allegations.
“Today the UN’s Special Coordinator for the Middle East Peace Process made peace harder to achieve by distorting history and international law before the Security Council,” the spokesman, David Keyes, said. “It is not the presence of Jews, who have lived in the West Bank and Jerusalem for thousands of years, that is a barrier to peace. Rather, it is the unceasing efforts to deny that historical connection and a refusal to recognize that Jews are not foreign to Judea.
“The claim that it is illegal for Jews to build in Jerusalem is as absurd as saying Americans can’t build in Washington or the French can’t build in Paris,” he added. “The Palestinian demand to ethnically cleanse their future state of Jews is outrageous and should be condemned by the United Nations instead of being embraced by it.”
The remarks come nearly a year into an upsurge in violence and terrorism. Since October of last year, 35 Israelis and four foreign nationals have been killed in a wave of Palestinian stabbing, car-ramming, and shooting attacks. At least 214 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli security forces in the same period, some two-thirds of them while carrying out attacks against Israelis, and the rest during clashes with troops, mostly in the West Bank, the Israeli army says.
Times of Israel staff contributed to this report.
NO…. not the UN…. but BB netanyahu would have us beleive that it was illegal and illegitimate.
How do I know that fact?
Well, in all his 2+ terms he has never once uttered these words or any variation thereof:
“JEWISH SETTLEMENT IN YS IS LEGAL AND LEGITIMATE”
If the PM cant say it why expect others to say it?