Zero-sum histography: The Palestinian assault upon history and the complicity of the west
By Paul Merkley, The Bayview Review,
It was not Abbas’s party (Fatah) but Hamas that won the mandate of January, 2006, after which the leader of Hamas, Ismail Haniyeh, was appointed Prime Minister of the Palestine Authority by the President (February, 2006.) But the ensuing round of assassinations of Hamas figures by Fatah figures and vice versa led Hamas’ leaders to conclude that more could be gained by quitting Ramallah, the administrative capital pro tem of Palestine, seizing all of Gaza, liquidating the leading Fatah figures there, and proclaiming themselves to be the rightful rulers of Palestine. Haniyeh continues to call himself Prime Minister of Palestine although much of our media is under the impression that Gaza is a sovereign entity or at least a Province and that Haniyeh is Prime Minister (or something) of that. He has no more right to any of his titles than Abbas has to the title of President, as the tenure of the Parliament elected in 2006 has also run out.
This embarrassing truth is never hinted at by our governments – not by the government of Canada, not by the Government of the United States, and, most incongruously of all, not by the government of Israel. Our elected politicians go on wining and dining “President Abbas” out of a Machiavellian calculation that if anything is ever to be rescued from the long-collapsed Peace Process we have to pretend to have a “Partner for Peace” that once got himself elected. It is all one patronizing fantasy – this notion of an emergent Palestinian democracy, embodied in the courageous, beleaguered leadership of the Palestine Authority. It is Orwellian double-think, kept alive by the agreement among media, politicians and opinion-elites that titles can have whatever meaning it is convenient to give to them so long as the cause of achieving peace through democracy is served.
In pretending not to notice the illegitimacy of the Abbas regime we are stooping to acceptance of the congenital contempt for historical fact that has bedeviled the political history of Islam since Muhammad proclaimed his message nearly fourteen centuries ago.
On September 13, 1993, a splendid ceremony was heldon the White House Lawn to praise the government of Israel and the leaders of the terrorist group, Palestine Liberation Organization, as heroic peacemakers, worthy of inclusion among history’s noblest spirits. To meet the needs of this unprecedented occasion, the records of Yasir Arafat and the records of his closest companions had to be moved off the shelves, their origins as terrorists quickly forgotten. If the past was to be referred to at all, the emphasis was to be on redemption. For example, the freedom fighter, Abu Mazen, who coordinated fund-raising for the Munich Olypmic massacre, was henceforth to be referred to by us (but not by the Palestinians themselves) by a civilian name, Mahmoud Abbas. Abbas was quickly redesigned as a family man, dedicated from his beginnings to diplomacy, a serious, benign scholarly gentleman, whose greatest love was the study of history. Abbas, does, indeed, hold an advanced degree in History. He earned it at the Patrice Lumumba University in Moscow, designed by the Soviet Union for the advanced training of foreign revolutionaries. (Since 1992, this University has been called the People’s Friendship University of Russia.)
While at PLU, Mahmoud Abbas wrote a doctoral thesis, The Connection between the Nazis and the Leaders of the Zionist Movement, later published (but only in Arabic) by a Jordanian publisher under a title that (we are told) would read in English: The Other Side: the Secret Relationship Between Nazism and Zionism. Mazen’s book presents a deconstructionist understanding of the Holocaust, beginning with challenge of the generally accepted numbers of victims. “Many scholars,” notes Dr. Abbas, “have debated the figure of six million figure of victims of the Holocaust and reached stunning conclusions fixing the number of Jewish victims at only a few hundred thousand… It seems that the interest of the Zionist movement, however, is to inflate this figure [to six million] … in order to gain the solidarity of international public opinion with Zionism.” There were, in any case, no gas chambers.
This demonstration of vagueness and obfuscation about matters long settled by scholarship tells us everything we need to know about Abbas’s qualification to be called an historian. Yet, the official BCC News Profile describes Abbas as “A highly intellectual man, Abbas studied law in Egypt before doing a Ph.D. in Moscow. He is the author of several books,” while the New York Times has described him as “a lawyer and historian.”
Nowadays, Abbas’s scholarly and polemical skills go to vilification of Israelis and Jews. He sets his sheepskin up front as token of his scholarly soundness while he belittles the history of Israel and the Jews and demonstrates that nobody ever really intended there to be a Jewish state. As diplomacy dedicated to the Peace Process has gone into deep freeze, Abbas has all the time in the world to badmouth Israel, its undeserved reputation for liberalism, for education, for research for science. Mahmoud Abbas and other principal figures in the Palestine Authority use the prestige of their titles to pursue in international media and at the UN a two-sided campaign of aggrandizement of Palestine and belittlement of Israel. Abbas’s scholarly labours have led him to the conclusion that the so-called State of Israel is not fit to be a neighbour of Palestine.
The latest breakthrough in the PA’s propaganda offensive has been its success in establishing in the minds of our scholars, our leaders of opinion and, with truly resounding success, our churchmen the counter-factual theorem that Palestine is a ancient and distinguished while Israel is a fraud.
Here is the syllogism:
- Palestine is real; Palestine has always been here; the Palestinian People have always been here.
- Israel is not real. Israel is an invention of the mid-Twentieth century AD, the product of European imperialism, foisted upon the world by a Zionist conspiracy in control of international diplomacy.
For example: Palestinian Authority TV News hews consistently to the PA policy of denying the history of Jewish presence in Jerusalem and in particular the existence at any time of a Jewish Temple. In a report about Israel’s excavations on the Temple Mount exposing part of the Western Wall, PA TV stated:
-
“There’s [an Israeli] race against the clock to complete the excavations in search of [Jerusalem’s] Temple that exists only in the minds of radical organizations ….[The Israelis] falsify historical facts by linking them to Jewish history, the traces of which don’t exist in our land.”
Israel’s excavations of the Western Wall have nothing to do with any archeological project, PA authorities declaim, but are cover for a plot to destroy the al-Aqsa Mosque from below.
Palestinian “historiography” (if sheer assertion without reference to any documentary or archeological evidence can be dignified by such a term) asserts that until the day before yesterday the Jews, or Israelis, call them what you will, never resided in this area, never had a Kingdom, never had a temple….Among recent lunatic examples are: “Moses was a Muslim who led Muslims in Exodus from Egypt, says a PA university lecturer on PA/ Israel’s conquest of the Land of Israel defined as ‘The first Palestinian liberation through armed struggle to liberate Palestine” (April 2, 2012); and “There never was a Temple… for the Jews …. [says PA Mufti.] They [the Jews] want to say or suggest that this place (Temple Mount) was once, according to their claim, a Temple. However, in truth, there never was a Temple in any period, nor was there, at any time, any place of worship for the Jews or others at the Al-Aqsa Mosque site (built on the Temple Mount, 705 CE).” Palestinian TV, Jan. 5, 2012.]
In order to keep this free-floating dogma unsullied, Muslim religious authorities on the Temple Mount have been hauling away to garbage dumps the debris resulting from their building projects on the site. When Israeli scholars find and display artifacts clearly illustrating the presence of the People of Israel or of the Temple of the Jews, Palestinian authorities simply claim them as proofs of “Palestinian” presence.
Keen as they are on siding with the victims of Israeli aggression, our cultural elites and, most distressing of all, our church leaders today indulge these knuckle-dragging assertions about Palestine and Palestine’s history for tactical purposes: they believe that polemical solidarity with the Palestinian victims will make it possible for us to keep Palestine’s “elected leaders” in the great cause of moving towards the Day of Peace.
Why should we care about these assertions about long-gone days? We should care because all this double-think is doing great damage to truth. We know that no historical commentary is ever free of self-serving bias. Bias occurs because of the human weakness of the historians and the sources they deal with. But in our western tradition no party ever justifies or admits distortion of historical fact for political advantage – although it can happen easily enough. On the other side, the Muslim side, distortion of historical fact has always been done boldly and on the grandest scale and always with impunity. This is because the methods of history have never developed on Islamic soil. The Qur’an itself is based upon the most blatant manipulation of history…..
@ dweller:
dweller Said:
Capo di tutti Pali
@ dweller:
I had a dream:
Kate and William adopted a little Jewish girl and she became the next queen of England according to the new succession laws in England.
Wouldn’t it be wonderful!
Then the Islamists in Londinistan would have their very own Jewish Queen.
Nobody would mind in the UK because they are all multicultural and civilized and prejudice doesn’t exist there at all, not at all!
What things may come…
@ C.R.:
Sure is HARD to avoid arriving at that conclusion.
For the most and notwithstanding the multitude of ignorant useful idiots–those who promote the palestinian lie are at heart anti-Semites; they do not have any love for the murdering Arab squatters–it is about promoting their hatred of Israel.
I wish someone would explain to the Western media and incredibly gullible following sockpuppets that when the Palestinian Terrorists have their demonstrations in North America and say “Free Palestine” that it doesn’t mean they are under oppression, and need to be ‘freed’, it means they want to take Israel from Israelis , kill all the Israelis and rename it Palestine. That is what they mean by “Free Palestine” – they are in fact waging Jihad not having “peace protests”.
They rewrite daily existence – they oppress our culture and complain we oppress them, they attack and kill Israeli civilians and complain of Israeli aggression.
And the biggest lie is the lie they have told all their own people – that Israel has taken something from them and they need to get it back. The fact is they never had anything and what they have is more that they ever had and is because Israel gave it to them.
This is the “cause for War’ that they instill in every citizen starting in childhood – Israel has taken something from them.
So you can’t give them anything, negotiation is useless – they want everything and they want to wage war – an unending Jihad.
It’s a mistake to leave Afghanistan- the next attack on America will be Al-Queda style five to seven cities at once – an atack from which America may not recover.
The only way America will survive is if it launches an all out first strike on all the Islamic terrorist countries and states – immediately.
@ keelie:
More like capo di tutti capi.
Right now, with all the nations grovelling at his feet, Abbas can claim to be the “President of Presidents”.
…
If constitutionality meant anything in American circles, husein, the bastard, should be judged a usurper; and if legitimacy meant anything in our media (…hmmmm let me see…. CNN? BBC?, MSNBC?, NYT, WAPO? I don’t think so!)
Ok. So now what? They are rewriting history.
Is this surprising ? No it is isn’t in fact it is to be expected!
It only becomes significant if Israel does nothing about it.
And to be clear, I do not meanANOTHER big round of hasbara and justification and ‘yes, but look I have here a document…’
That would be shooting ourselves in the feet (both. repeatedly.)
Once again, there is a small window of opportunity described very well in another thread by both mr. Ross and yamit, as to what should be next:
Annex y&s
Take over gaza and Sinai (we all know that morsi is planning to follow the kkkoran to a ‘t’ and look for Jews behind any rock Orr tree)
Immediately expell all foreign correspondents for being the enemy that they are. (Could definitely throw in a few ha’aretz ‘journalists’ while we’re at it)
WITH NO APOLOGIES NOR JUSTIFICATIONS.