How many people realize that the names of most Palestinian Arab towns are proof that the Jews dwelled in Judea and Samaria before the Arab conquerors arrived? Even the name Jordan means “descends from Dan,” one of the 12 tribes of Israel.
During President Obama’s second term in office, Secretary of State John Kerry, like his boss and other members of the same peapod (Samantha Power, Susan Rice, Joe Biden, Chuck Hagel, etc.), liked to warn Israel about such things as its isolation and alienation if it did not agree to Arab demands to return to its pre-’67 war, ’49 armistice lines (they were never borders) which made it an over-sized ghetto, 9-15 miles wide at its waist, where most of its population and infrastructure are located.
President George W. Bush commented that Texas had driveways larger than that. I don’t know about driveways, but I also don’t doubt the size of some Lone Star ranches. And I’m pretty sure Mrs. Obama had to travel farther than that for shopping trips to Target.
Others, like President Jimmy Carter, supposedly worried/worry (and even wrote books) about Israel’s soul and looming “apartheid nature” if it insists on the more secure, defensible, real borders that UNSC Resolution 242 promised in the wake of the ’67 fighting–a war Israel was forced to fight after being blockaded by Egypt (a casus belli), shelled by Jordan, abandoned by the UN Emergency Force placed in Sinai after the ’56 war (largely fought over another blockade and acts of terror), and other hostile acts and constant threats of annihilation.
All of 242’s architects (Lord Caradon, Eugene Rostow, etc.)–and Presidents Johnson, Reagan, and others (including George W. Bush in his letter to Prime Minister Ariel Sharon)–agreed that Israel would never return to those pre-’67 Auschwitz lines.
That, dear readers, is what the “settlement” issue is mostly all about…besides Jews having both modern, religious, and historical connections to Judea and Samaria (only since the 20th century, called the “West Bank”) for over three thousand years.
Question: Was Jesus born in Bethlehem of the ‘West Bank’ or Bethlehem of Judea? Ask the Gospels- Matthew, in fact.
Indeed, many or most Arab settlements, er, “villages,” were named after their original, pre-7th century C.E. Arab conquest Hebrew locations. Think Bethlehem (Beit Lehem, where King David was born, his great-grandparents Ruth and Boaz lived, Jesus was born, etc.); al-Khalil (Hebron/Chevron, where most Hebrew Patriarchs and Matriarchs are buried and David was crowned King of Israel); Beitin (Beth El, named by Jacob); Jenin (Ein Ganim); Selum (Shilo); Tequa (Tekoa); Silwan (Shiloach); Batir (Beitar–Shimon Bar Kochba’s last stand in the 2nd major Jewish revolt against Rome in 135 C.E.); El-Jib (Giv’on); and others as well. The post Arab conquest place names, so obviously based on ancient Hebrew names, are a source for archaeologists who use them to decide where to begin excavations of ancient Jewish sites.
Even the Jordan River and the Arab nation of Jordan itself (carved out of almost 80% of the original 1920 Mandate of Palestine in 1922) is named for the Hebrew tribe of Dan which lived in that area (Yarden–“descends from Dan”). All of this, of course, only adds insult to injury when those of Kerry’s ilk lecture Jews on such matters. Check this link out for more.
In the wake of President Trump’s historic decision to finally recognize and formalize the Jews’ 3,000 year old connection to Jerusalem (how many other peoples/nations can make such a valid claim to their own capitals?) by pledging to move the American embassy there, Kerry recently returned to his earlier shtick (only back burnered when milking “‘Progressive” Israelites for campaign funds)…After all, who knows what’s best for Israel–Obama’s peapod mate or Jews themselves?
Like most others of the Democrat persuasion these days (and I once voted for them in the past), Kerry prefers Jews as victims for whom he can cry crocodile tears of sympathy. And yes, I know that his family was originally Kohn, not Kerry–but that’s another story. He can give a decent speech regarding the Holocaust, I’m sure.
But when it comes to empathy for real, in-the-flesh, imperfect, live Jews, that’s another story.. After all, his Arafat-in-suit buddies are so perfect.
It has been confirmed that Kerry recently told an emissary of Fatah and the Palestinian Authority’s Mahmoud Abbas–Israel’s alleged peace partner who shelled out around $400 million last year alone to families of shahids, Arab “martyred” heroes who murdered Jews in cold blood (a good amount of the sum coming from American tax payers courtesy of the State Department)–to convey to Abbas, among other juicy things about Trump himself, to “hold on and be strong…play for time…and not yield to President Trump’s demands.”
Like Kerry (who hints at a presidential run in 2020), Carter, Obama, and others claiming friendship towards an Israel that agrees to stay within its sardine can of a state, the Czechs and Slovaks had Chamberlain and other such “friends” too in 1938. Those friends also demanded that they sacrifice themselves for “peace in our time.” Soon, Hitler overran them and most of Europe as well. And had it not been for the Russian Front, Chamberlain’s England would most likely have been speaking German today.
For an Israel one needs a magnifying glass to find on a world globe, whether a victim of careful deliberation or naiveté, dead is dead. If Arabs do what they do to each other daily, imagine what they would do with “their” kilab yahud–Jew dogs–if given half a chance. Unfortunately, we don’t have to just imagine…
Overwhelmingly, Americans realize thatjustice does not demand that the sole, resurrected, minuscule nation of the Jews sacrifice itself on the petroleum-greased altar of international hypocrisy so that Arabs may obtain their 22nd state–and second, not first, in “Palestine,” the name the Emperor Hadrian’s ancient Rome gave to Judaea after the Judaeans’–Jews’–second costly revolt for freedom and independence against the imperial conqueror of much of the known world. Contemporary Roman historians had much to say about those events themselves.
Around that same time, a great spiritual leader and contemporary of Jesus in Judaea, Rabbi Hillel, said “If I am not for myself, then who will be? And, if I am only for myself, then what am I?”
Jews, collectively, have been disproportionately represented among those who have shown compassion and concern for Hillel’s “other” over the millennia. It’s no accident that the great social movements for the betterment of the human condition have a disproportionate amount of Jews in leadership and membership roles. Look to the Hebrew Bible itself for the roots of this.
It took Commodore Uriah P. Levy to ban flogging from the United States Navy in 1850. Read the Prophet Isaiah for what’s required regarding the poor, the widowed, and the orphan. Find out about Samuel Gompers, Emma Lazarus, and so on…And Jews have cared about–and tried over and over again to reach fair compromises with–Arabs as well. How have Arabs treated their own scores of millions, non-Arab competitors in a region Arabs claim solely for themselves? When’s the last time the likes of a Kerry lectured them?
Regardless, it’s long past due that Jews start taking the first part of Rabbi Hillel’s teaching more seriously. You can’t have peace when your alleged partner only envisions your own peace of the grave.
Thank G-d, America once again has a leader who appears to understand all this. Let’s wish him success and Divine guidance in all his worthy endeavors–those involving true peace and relative justice for all peoples in the Middle East…not just, but also not excluding, Arabs as well.
The author is an educator who has done extensive doctoral studies in Mid-East Affairs and has conducted counter-Arab propaganda programs for college youth. He gives lectures and participates in debates around the U.S. Read his new book to be found at http://q4j-middle-east.com.
The beginning of your article is very interesting because it fits in with something i have been following up for the past few months. I was checking on the veracity of the book Plaestinae ex Monumentis Veteribus Illustrata, by Hadriani Relandi otherwise Professor of Semitic Languages Adriaan Reland, of Utrecht University. The book was written around 1695-6 and published in 1714 having 6 editions. Very popular and used by ll experts after him as a reference. Realnd had a tremendous reputation for integrity, care, expertise, and was a master in Cartography, Semitic languages for which he held the Utrecht Chair or his lifetime, as well as philology etc.nd much more, a polymath and child genius who mastered Latin and Greek fluently by age 11 and finished his university course at age 16,.
His book stated clearly that he’d had a demographic investigation of Palestine done, and a census taken of all the 2500 towns villages and cities mentioned in the Mishna and Torah. He FOUND NOT A SINGLE LOCATION NAME OF ARABIC ORIGIN, They were all Hebrew names that had been transliterated into the closest sounding Arabic equivalent.
He also said that there were NO Arabs in Palestine then, except a few wandering nomad seasonal Bedouin. The rest were about 75-80% Jews the rest Christians nd Samaritans. The only settled Arabs found were in Nablus a single family of 120 people.
I wanted to know more, because The internet said that he was not able to go on that particular trip because of his father’s poor health. I found that a Symposium at utrecht University, dedicated to Reland, is taking place in Feb, likely on the 400 year anniversary of his death from smallpox. I’ve been in touch with several of the Utrecht professors, and particularly the one in charge of arranging the Symposium.
He confirmed that Reland was not able to reach Palestine, becuse of his father’s ill health, but used the most meticulous sources for everything he ever did. So we can take it that both he and you are correct in the matter you began your article with. Also, that we can believe that there were no Arabs in Palestine at the end of the 17th century. but many Jews.
Which is what I always felt, and am now convinced of.