By Isi Leibler
I was more saddened than angered when I learned that the North American Board of Trustees of the Union for Reform Judaism condemned Israel’s plans for construction in Jerusalem and the E1 area because it highlights Israel’s failure to adequately explain our position even to American Jews. Were Jews at grassroots level better informed of the facts, no Jewish leadership group would have dared to adopt such an approach.
Former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert’s false and outrageous outbursts in the US, even stooping to accusing Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu of initiating this move solely to humiliate President Obama, undoubtedly contributed to this in no small measure. Olmert was supported by the far left, former American Jewish ambassador to Israel Dan Kurtzer, who dismissed the Israeli initiative as a crude effort to garner votes at the forthcoming elections.
I would wager that the vast majority of American Reform Jews are unaware that the ongoing hysterical condemnation of Israel over settlements relates to no more than 2% of the territories. Or that much of the housing construction planned is merely catering to natural population growth of existing settlements. And that the construction currently being condemned is limited either to suburbs of Jerusalem or within the framework of the agreed settlement blocs that every peace plan assumes will remain within the borders of the Jewish state.
The E1 area comprises of 12 square kilometers and is adjacent to Maale Adumim, a city inhabited by 40,000 Jewish residents located just 4 miles from Jerusalem. That this city will remain within the boundaries of Israel was reaffirmed by every political leader including Yitzhak Rabin (who at the outset of the Oslo accords even provided the mayor of Maale Adumim with annexation documents for E1), Shimon Peres, Ehud Barak, Yossi Beilin (the architect of the Oslo accords), Ehud Olmert and Tzipi Livni. In the course of the Camp David Accords, President Clinton also endorsed the area as being within the future boundaries of Israel.
As a quid pro quo to Prime Minister Sharon’s 2004 unilateral withdrawal from Gaza, the Bush Administration agreed that taking into account demographic changes, areas encompassing the major settlement blocs would be retained by Israel. However,this was indirectly challenged by President Obama in his May 2011 speech which called for the 1967 borders plus swaps as a starting point for negotiations. But anyone seriously involved in Middle East affairs understands that these areas can never be separated from the Jewish state.
The Palestinians and other international critics falsely insist that by adopting this path, Israel would deny contiguity to a Palestinian state. This is untrue. The government has provided for a bypass road to be accessible at all times, guaranteeing Palestinians right of passage throughout the area.
For over 10 years, Israel deferred to international requests to delay construction in the area in order to appease the Palestinians. But even after Netanyahu’s unprecedented and unconditional ten month settlement freeze, the Palestinian Authority still refused to negotiate with Israel. Instead, PA chair Mahmoud Abbas continued to incite hatred against Israel, even denying any Jewish connection to Jerusalem. After he defiantly abrogated the Oslo Accords by promoting UN recognition, the Israeli government felt that it had waited long enough and decided to proceed with the long-delayed construction in this area.
In the particularly volatile and hostile environment which surrounds us, one might question the wisdom of the government making needlessly provocative proclamations about these issues rather than proceeding quietly and dispensing with such strident advance announcements. And the issue should be presented as reflecting Israel’s legitimate national interests and in no way an obstacle to establishing a Palestinian state. It is certainly wrong and conveys a false message if portrayed as a punishment for the misbehavior of the PA.
But it would probably not have made the slightest difference. Most of the international community, especially the Europeans, were relieved to distance themselves from the supportive role they were recently obliged to assume towards Israel by endorsing its right of self-defense in the face of Hamas rocket attacks. Even then, many remained critical, accusing Israel of employing excessive force and failing to respond proportionately.
They were also visibly overjoyed to draw closer to our “moderate peace partner” the corrupt Mahmoud Abbas, who at the UN received standing ovations from virtually the entire gathering after delivering a speech replete with lies and hatred designed to demonize us.
The hysterical condemnation of the Jewish state for approving home construction in an area adjacent to its capital, on barren, uninhabited land which neither displaced Palestinians nor altered the demography of the region, is bizarre. No distinction is made between housing construction in outlying settlements – which the government has restricted – and the major settlement blocs which will unquestionably remain within the boundaries of Israel.
Double standards are shamelessly applied. Nobody takes into account that two successive Israeli Prime Ministers effectively offered the Palestinians over 95% of disputed territories but were rejected. The Quartet undertook to guarantee implementation of the Oslo accords, yet aside from the United States, all its members abandoned Israel by abstaining or voting in favor of the PA abrogation. In so doing they repudiated UN Security Council resolution 242 and actually rewarded the PA for materially breaching its commitments.
During the Gaza conflict the Western powers called continuously on Israel to act proportionately. But there was no such proportionality in relation to their condemnation of Israel over the construction issue. No indignation was expressed during the years when missiles were launched against our civilians. No criticisms were voiced against the PA and Hamas for inciting against Israel or of their sanctification of “martyrs” who murdered Israeli women and children. No country condemned PA chairman Mahmoud Abbas – who accuses Israel of “ethnic cleansing” – for proclaiming that not a single Jew will be permitted to live in a Palestinian state. The international community responded with a greater uproar against Israel home construction than to the ongoing, obscene atrocities committed by both parties in the Syrian civil war. Little was said when North Korea breached its undertakings and renewed the testing of international missiles. When Egyptian President Morsi sought to impose dictatorial rule in his country, there was barely a murmur of protest. Surely the application of such double standards by the international community towards Israel amounts to ignorance, hypocrisy, double standards or a combination thereof.
With the existential threat looming from Iran’s efforts to obtain a nuclear bomb, there is indeed a desperate need for us to reverse the tide flowing against us in the war of ideas, gain support internationally and strengthen our standing with our most important ally, the United States.
However Jerusalem and Maale Adumim and the major adjacent settlement blocs will remain part of Israel and this is one issue concerning which we must remain steadfast. And we cannot be expected to freeze construction indefinitely because the Palestinian Authority leaders refuse to negotiate while they proclaim a willingness to unite with the genocidal Hamas, whose leader Khaled Mashal only a few days ago again publicly reiterated his pledge to wipe away the Jewish state through military action.
@ C.R.:
With all due respect, C.R., you might want to consider that since ALL the parties in this particular matter — those on the right side AND those on the wrong side — are JEWS
— that there’s no need — and might well be some (unintended) mischief — to be using the term “evil” here together with “Jews,” or to be using the term “Jewish” together with “rebellion-against-God.”
@ yamit82:
Ooh, multiple choice. Love it.
Leibler, instead of wondering why the De-, i mean, Reformed, don’t understand the settlements in E-1 because they are so easy to understand, why don’t you try to figure out why your sorry ass supported Sharon’s Expulsion from Gaza, as THAT was incredibly easy to understand that it would be both a colossal fiasco and a Chilul Hashem.
@ Shy Guy:
The last time I saw Peres in person was picking him up from the ground where he had fallen dead drunk. Was in old Jaffa about 2am. I’m not saying he is an alcoholic but the piece of ofal then didn’t even know where he was. At the time he was out of office and leader of the Labor opposition.
The Israeli media protects these crud from any personal negative public scrutiny.
Isn’t he long overdue to ‘kick the can’?
Interesting historical NOTE: In those days there were more MK’s from Labor opposing the withdrawal from Sinai than from the Likud. I even saw with my own eyes some of them actually crying over the deal like Shlomo Hillel.
@ C.R.:
C.R. Said:
Like killing those godless and rebellious Jews?
Like throwing all the gentiles out of the country?
Like tearing down all non Jewish (pagan) places of worship?
What else is to be expected from evil Jews? more of the same! This isn’t just a lack of knowledge as the author suggests–its a Jewish rebellion against God issue; those who know and understand the Tanakh–know what to do.
Yes, it is Israel’s fault. When Shimon Peres went on FOX news, after 9/11 and before a very sympathetic toward Israel host, Sean Hannity, shamelessly praised Arafat, as a peacemaker and accused Ari Sharon of belligerence and thwarting peace in the Middle East.
Then you have Barak, Olmert, Livni, not even mentioning Israel’s opportunistic intellectuals working against Israel. At some point, Israel’s leaders, political and intellectual decided that it is all right to spit at their own country and side with the enemy. And, at some point, the Israelis allowed them to get away with it. Peres should have been made a pariah, not a President, after smearing Israeli leaders and policies abroad, while publicly praising the terrorists and enemies of Israel.
As for American Jews, we happen to be quite opportunistic, as well; it was fine to side with Israel and Israelis, when Israel was universally admired for beating the combined Arab Armies well supplied and trained by the Soviet Union, in six days; it is another story to support Israel when all the big guys are ganging up against it — it actually requires courage, in case some influential people don’t invite you to their next party.
This is a terrible organization. It serves as a network of increasingly anti-Israel clergy who seek to undermine the security of the Jewish state, and compromise the security of our brethren in the Middle East. They reek of bad judgment and ultimately give aid to the anti-Israel forces that are increasingly vocal and active in the Democratic Party, up to and including the White House. Where were they on the calls by Hamas and Abbas to dismantle the Jewish state? Why are they standing on the side of genocide of our fellow Jews in the Middle East? They haven’t said anything about the abrogation of Oslo, and go berserk over a few apartments, yet are silent on the threatened destruction of the Jewish state and its people.
The secular Jews in the U.S. who may affiliate with the Reform or Conservative movements need to be held to account. It is not entirely Israel’s fault that these so-called Jews are so ignorant and misguided. Orthodox Jews in America are not fooled and neither are many American gentiles who can clearly discern right from wrong and friend from foe. It is time that Israel talk tough to these delicate hot house flowers and make it clear that Israel owes them nothing. It will be refreshing to see a strong Israel telling them that they have no influence. Years ago Netanyahu also said that whenever he visits to the U.S. he knows that Israel’s best friends are the Evangelicals. If the leftist Jews don’t like it they can lump it. Let them feel rejected and know they are not needed.
Mr. Leibler, all of Yehuda and Shomron must remain part of Israel. Your perpetual pragmatic worries of “vhat vill dem goyim zay” and a lack of faith in Hashem’s guiding hand, was the failure of the Israel in the “Generation of the Spies”, which was corrected in certain ways by the Hashmonaim and the miracles of Chanuka. Shaking hands with Arafat didn’t work for you. Nor did Sharon. Nor did Bush. Nor did the Roadmap. Nor does Netanyahu. When will you take a hint and snap out of you complacency?! Doesn’t banging your head against the wall over and over again hurt just a little?