Blumenthal backs up his claims with links and videos but you cavalierly dismissed his case last time around…and keep in mind he came out with this March 2022 right at the beginning of the war. Still valid today only more so.
Scroll down and you’ll see Zelensky giving one of his Nazis “Hero of Ukraine” Award.
More from Grayzone later.
https://thegrayzone.com/2022/0
@Reader Don’t sell yourself short. Who says painting by the numbers isn’t art? And after a few swigs of Manischewitz, it becomes high art.
@Sebastien Zorn
You are an artistic person, and I am not.
I prefer to express myself with my own words rather than with someone else’s videos and music.
I don’t like long sentences and comments myself, so I am going to return to posting numbered lists to express my opinions to make them easier to understand.
@Felix Here I’m trying to be funny and you are taking my suggestions seriously.
Wouldn’t it be wild if Archaeologists were to discover that that’s how Christianity and Islam got started? 😀
If only it were a religion.
But sadly it is the opposite. We have no right to anything. And our existence as a body of ideas has only one foundation – reason
Not creating a tangent here but…
That is why I see the refutation of this Fascism of the Right against Fauci in the work of scientists to which I have drawn attention to
Anyway her name is Angela Rasmussen based in Saskatchewan University. I supplied the link.
This too is important to me.
I believe this is worth repeating. I notice Steve Kramer comes close to this essentially philosophical position but Steve has never built a party.
But that kind of statement is important
There are big lessons in Ukraine and how an essential Fascism seeks to split us off from a long history before Putin’s “invasion” AND the pressure of this force, an ideological force, is intense.
In Israel’s case it goes back thousands of years. Very very difficult task is the defence of Jews against Antisemitism
@Felix It would be easier to get the Trotsky religion off the ground if there were sightings of him having risen from the dead like Elvis Presley or Jim Morrison. Still, I thought of a name for the souvenir store,”Trotsky’s Tchotckes”
As for a suitable mantra, I’m torn between Om mane Padme Trotsky and Om mane Trotsky hum. One would be Trotsky is in the Lotus and the other the Jewel is in Trotsky which sounds painful even though it rhymes better. Reminds me of hemorroids or kidney stones. Difficult sort of decisions. That’s why they pay religious editors the big bucks.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jew_in_the_Lotus
@Reader https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4gi9zFRBCIM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qzfXxkHrIBM
@Sebastien Zorn
I think it is very unfair of you to equate your ability to “understand my thought” with the intellectual abilities of the people in those YouTube videos that you’ve just posted.
You may have some difficulty with abstract reasoning but eventually you get it!
@Reader
😀 😀 😀
@Reader I understand your thought.
https://youtu.be/lj3iNxZ8Dww
https://youtu.be/u6QTve8XSv8
My comment was deleted, reposting:
Reader
March 3, 2023 at 8:44 am
@Sebastien Zorn
All I said is that there has to be a formal completion of the population exchange which started after the war.
No, I do not know how to do it, and just because I suggested it doesn’t give you the right to demand detailed plans from me – I am not Israel’s government.
I think that Israel has to state publicly and firmly, for the whole world to hear, that this has to be done, and that this is a normal and accepted way of doing things in such cases (e.g., India and Pakistan), and that continuing the “peace” process, demanding “territorial concessions” from Israel and leaving it within indefensible borders in order to create an umpteenth Arab state is an existential threat to Israel and to the world Jewry.
I am sorry, I am not into mass murder/forced expulsion solution to territorial problems, and this kind of solution will spell the end of Israel (I am not denying that terrorists must be punished, expelled, etc.).
@Sebastien Zorn
All I said is that there has to be a formal completion of the population exchange which started after WWII.
No, I do not know how to do it, and just because I suggested it doesn’t give you the right to demand detailed plans from me – I am not Israel’s government.
I think that Israel has to state publicly and firmly, for the whole world to hear, that this has to be done, and that this is a normal and accepted way of doing things in such cases (e.g., India and Pakistan), and that continuing the “peace” process, demanding “territorial concessions” from Israel and leaving it within indefensible borders in order to create an umpteenth Arab state is an existential threat to Israel and to the world Jewry, and that Israel sees itself eventually existing in its Biblical borders and bringing in all the Jews from the Diaspora.
If the “world community” doesn’t like, let it jump in the lake or sea, or ocean of its choice.
I am sorry, I am not into mass murder/forced expulsion solution to territorial problems, and this kind of solution will spell the end of Israel (I am not denying that terrorists must be punished, expelled, etc.).
@Reader @Felix I have to guess, see, because you have evaded answering every single one of my questions. My guess is you haven’t thought this through. Analysis. What analysis? It’s all vague. contradictory hypotheses and prophetic pronouncements in a vaccuum.
@Reader Or do you imagine incentives to leave would influence more than some of them? Whatever is done will have to be done by force but in stages which is the strategy of the PLO, as well. They haven’t missed opportunities. They’ve exploited them cleverly. This is a long fight to the finish and no one will fight our battles for us.
@Reader I haven’t forgotten. You said you are opposed to driving them out by force, but you insist on claiming all of biblical Israel all at once and you want to appeal to the UN to hand the entire land from the brook of Egypt to the Euphrates to the Jews. You don’t say how the Arabs are to be removed. Right after you cite the impossibility of driving out 4 million Arabs, the one thing you were right about. Do you expect the UN to drive them out? And to where? As if it could even if it ever would want to or as if a globalist sponsor would be desirable.
None of this makes the slightest sense!
@Sebastien Zorn
It looks like you have completely forgotten what we were discussing.
Why don’t you go back to where it started and reread it because I am not going to copy and paste it here to remind you.
@Reader
What does that even mean when entire terrorist communities are allowed to remain in the path of Jews? You are not making any sense. Excuse me, Arab terrorists. Galant just imprisoned two Jews under administrative detention right after they were freed for lack of evidence! He is a traitor who should be fired and expelled from Likud!
“The Lord your God will drive out those nations before you, little by little. You will not be allowed to eliminate them all at once, or the wild animals will multiply around you. 23 But the Lord your God will deliver them over to you, throwing them into great confusion until they are destroyed. 24 He will give their kings into your hand, and you will wipe out their names from under heaven. No one will be able to stand up against you; you will destroy them.”
Deuteronomy 7
https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Deuteronomy%207&version=NIV
@FelixQuigley
Your description of the situation is correct.
Sebastien either won’t or can’t understand what I am saying.
I don’t see why he thinks that both our ideas are mutually exclusive, i.e., why it is impossible to fight against terrorism short term while working on the long-term solution at the same time – the ongoing terrorism is proof that coexistence without the full population exchange is impossible.
I think if Trotsky decided to join Jabotinsky or, at least the Zionist cause in general, instead of devoting his life to saving mother Russia and the rest of the world from oppression, we could have had a state BEFORE the war.
The program which is our program the Trotskyist program today is there in the analysis by Joseph in 23 Reasons…
There cannot be ever a second Palestinian State. The great compromise was already made back in the 1920s with the cutting off of 78 per cent of the original area for the Jewish Homeland. This was done by Churchill of the forever meddling British Imperialist class, cornering the then young and inexperienced Jewish leadership into an ambush. But never again. East of the river was a mere 28 per cent of the whole. That was the promise of Churchill and Lloyd George but like the promises made in the Minsk Accords in 2014 and 2015 they were fraudulent promises to the Jews. On the eve of the Holocaust it was a terrible blow. It must never happen again. That is why I mention Trotsky and program. To be steadfast means being Trotskyist because we Trotskyists too have been tested by most serious events.
But that program while sacrosanct says nothing about the day to day living. In other words I refer to the tactics of the struggle which can be flexible by its very nature. As Sebastien says it is necessary to stop Jews being murdered not tomorrow but today.
I do not live there but seems to me – All the legalities are already in place.
In the meantime secure the area where Jews live by military means to prevent any Jew being harmed. By any and every means necessary.
If any person (as present Labour leader I have just heard opining on BBC World Service) opposes this course of action it must be termed and widely promulgated that they do not defend the lives of Jews.
It is therefore an issue of political leadership in Israel.
Other countries especially America should support the above. Not abstain but support. So this beckons to an international leadership. This is why I mention Trotsky. We are strong in science and we don’t have to be weak in numbers either.
@Felix Alternate response. I didn’t get a program. Usher! Damn, the lights are going down. The show is starting! Sshhh.
@Reader where the IDF is in control and all it woud take is a vote* by the Knesset without the interference of the legal mob. With a rightwing majority. Oh, but that’s a fantasy. I’m being led by my emotions, right? So, what’s your plan? Got one?
Prayer, aside.
(*Well, 6 votes, but who’s counting? 😀 )
@Felix I had a New Age upbringing and I’m always open to any combination of new or old superstitions that might bring luck. Where can I get my St. Trotsky medal? No, too Catholic. Crystals, then? Are you selling them? Can you post any effective mantras to St. Trotsky, preferably in Sanskrit? Maybe, “Om, mane padme Trotsky?”
@Reader
“Without killing or forcing out the Arabs”. Where they are not merely the majority but the entire population. How, when, pray tell? Should I get my calendar out? Are you counting on a miracle? Are you a religious as well as a Mrxist prophet, now? As Jews are murdered every day in Yesha, where Jews are the overwhelming majority.
Reader and Sebastien
The past must lead to the new and a great realistic yet true hopeful realism. Become committed to a Trotskyist leadership in Israel and with the internet fight for this can be from anywhere
The article here on Israpundit re hanging is a good example of gesture politics and replacing political struggle with an empty activism.
https://www.israpundit.org/europe-warns-israel-against-game-changer-death-penalty-legislation/
We have already got the correct program
Joseph…23 Reasons no second Arab state
https://www.israpundit.org/europe-warns-israel-against-game-changer-death-penalty-legislation/
@Sebastien Zorn
I mean that Jews will live in all of Yesha because all of Yesha will be Israel.
Why is it so difficult to figure out?
https://www.i24news.tv/en
@Reader What do you mean all of Yesha. Area C is the only place Jews live. The Arabs of Gaza and Areas A and B aren’t going anywhere in the forseeable future. So apply sovereignty to Area C and deport the violent Arab minority from Israel to the already Judenrein Arab occupied areas and seal the border between them.
The point is to get them out of striking disance of Jews.
That’s practical.And it could happen tomorrow.
You are the one who is too emotionally invested in millenial visions which are fantasies.
My entirely justified emotionalism is outrage for our poor, oppressed people. Sure Zionism, the Return began as a dream. It took 2,000 years.
Modern Political Zionism took 50 or 70 or 150, depending on how you measure it.
Jews are being murdered for being Jews every day in the Jewish state. This is unacceptable and unnecessary.