Dr. Aaron Lerner Date: 18 April 2013
“I believe the window for a two-state solution is shutting…I think we have
some period of time, a year, a year-and-a-half, or two years or it’s over.”
US Secretary of State John Kerry to the US House of Representatives Foreign
Affairs Committee 17 April 2013
Hope he is right that the window for a two-state solution is shutting.
And the sooner the better.
Because having a sovereign Palestinian state in our living room is anything
but the best option of a collection of bad options.
A truly sovereign Palestinian state is a terrible option.
It would be incredibly dangerous for Israel and a source of tremendous
instability for the entire neighborhood.
And when one considers just how challenging and unstable the region is these
days, the very last thing we can afford is to do is implement a program
based on declarations rather than solid arguments.
Mr. Kerry and his fellow travelers can proclaim a million times that the
creation of a sovereign Palestinian state would best serve Israel’s
security. But a silly remark made once or a billion times remains just
that. A silly remark.
We can most certainly speculate about worse case outcomes if there isn’t a
sovereign Palestinian state.
Life is full of risks.
But when one compares an option with close to 100% of having disastrous
results for the Jewish State to an array of possibilities – which include
bad outcomes having relatively low probabilities of ever taking place – the
choice is clear.
Mr. Kerry no doubt thought his remark would spur efforts to create a
sovereign Palestinian state.
Instead there is great relief in the idea that Secretary of State Kerry
suggests that if we can make it half way through President Obama’s second
term that this two state solution nonsense will finally be behind us.
Dr. Aaron Lerner, Director IMRA (Independent Media Review & Analysis)
More encouraging words from John F’in Kerry
Bernard Ross Said:
This is the real concern. However as long as Shia & Sunnis are at each other throat till the end of time, there should be less worries for the Jews. But Jews must remain on guard. People are dumb enough to repeat history.
steven l Said:
I think this was the position of the british white paper of 1939. It appears that after balfour the british did everything they could to renege on their own declaration: first seviering off trans jordan and then coming up with the white paper to deprive the jews of any interest. The aim of the europeans appears to be to keep whittling down the jewish portion until it no longer exists.
Short version: they are low life crooks and swindlers..
these things are clear in the documents leading to the LON and UN charterart80:
-the jewish people are to be encouraged to close settlement in their hational homeland of palestine.(right cannot legally expire even if the mandate is ended, assets and interests devolve to the beneficiary of a trust)
-the area west of the jordan was cut out from “palestine” and, according to british, therefore the mandate did not apply west of the jordan. However, no one has a legal argument for its applicaction west of the Jordan river after the jews were banned from settleing easet of the river.
The Jews were to be given political, civil and religious rights in Palestine and the arabs were given civil and religious rights. This was due to the arabs reciving political rights inthe other mandates created of syria and iraq.
steven l Said:
I am unfamiliar with this position. However, a serially slaughtered, swindled, extorted, libeled people would agree to anything to escape the insane pathologies of their chronic tormentors. A fleeing people who are murdered by their trustee(UK),murdered by their neighbors will accept any crumbs offered just to stay alive. a principle of law and morality: agreements made under duress are not legally binding or enforceable. this is the principle that Jews should invoke and execute to reverse the swindles of their current and endless tormentors: the europeans. It is the europeans, the age old jew killers, who are in the forefront of the current jew blood libels and who goad the arabs to the slaughter. The absence of the euros would end the conflict. The rest of the world is following their lead.
steven l Said:
Some, e.g. Wallace Brand, say that the land was in trust until the Jews were a majority.
steven l Said:
for some this is true.
Only Israels power can be relied upon, no alliances or agreements can substitute.
My current fear is that there may be an agreement under the table which has been evolving which includes GCC/US/Israel to reassert Sunni hegemony, weaken Irans shia/allawite surrogates of syria and hezbullah and allow the ascension of islamists controlled by qatar and saudi. This may work out for Israel if they next turn to Iraq and Iran now that syria and hezbullah are weakened and hamas has been weaned from Iran to sunni qatar. The gaza ceasefire and the Kurdish/turkish cease fire indicate this; also the faux pal state and the revival of the jordan confed.
Right now I am leaning to the existence of an unfolding agreement which moves the GCC away from the paradigm of the Israel card. It is possible that they realize that the Israeli card backfired and sent their usual sphere of influence into the arms of shia, persian, Iran and that this Iranian axis is a clear danger whereas Israel is not. Iranian internal de-stabilization of the monarchs is existential danger to them, Israel is only a danger when attacked. However, it could also be a trick which results in the surrounding of Israel by Islamists.
Mark Bernadiner Said:
Fully agree with this statement. Furthermore this was a creation of the WEST to eliminate the Jews.
Of interest and not resolved is the claim that a state for the Jews was not included in the Balfour declaration (Jewish home) but many years later, after 80% of the “home” was chopped away (given to create Jordan) and only at the time of the partition between Pal & Jews, baffles me. This was Abba Eban position and he jumped for it.
Then what was the long term purpose of the so called “Jewish home”? A new concentration camp in the ME??? or would it have evolved naturally into a Jewish state. Any information from anybody? This perhaps was a trick to get rid of the surviving Jews of the Holocaust!!!
Deception is a well known weapon for the Muslims!!!
So far Iran is fooling everyone!
SA has played that game for hundred years or more and they are slowly but surely infiltrating the US thanks to US greediness.
yamit82 Said:
I remember reading that a rebel leader had said, when they were fighting Assad in the golan, that Israel has nothing to fear from the jihadis because they will be moving to another arena when they were finished there. As many are foreign jihadis, and must be funded, I would think they will go where the money tells them to go. based on the Qatar/Hamas/egypt/ Israel cease fire there is the possibility that an arrangement is already in place. In any case, Syria and hezbullah are weakened now.
yamit82 Said:
The time appears optimum any time from now: Hezbullah and syria are weak, both cannot tolerate a war internally and with Israel. the status quo is good for Israel and for attacks on Iran. I would imgaine the way is clear through numerous nations airspace. Everyone is occupied. If al qaeda takes over in Syria then it should strengthen the possibilities of Israel seizing a buffer zone, it has apparently been involved with negotiating that with the rebels, there is also the Druze. I thinnk that the destabiliztion of Iran with a persian spring and the external forces will be tried before an attack, using the kurds, sunnis, azeris, jihadis.
yamit82 Said:
I would imagine that there might be a price if what is unfolding is a deal. However, my wager is that the GCC is more interested in Iran and shia rather than Israel. I would not be surprised if they are moving away from the pal vs Israel card. Their future cannot be sustained by playing the Israel card. It is possible that the ME may be redrawn along ethnic lines.
Two-State Solution has already been implemented
In compliance with the 1920 League of Nations Resolution, two-state solution was implemented in 1922 when british administration of occupied Israel allocated more than 70% of Israel territory to palestinian arabs and created Transjordan (now Jordan) where today over 90 percent of the population identify themselves as Palestinian Arabs. Every party, including UN, EU, US, etc., must respect League of Nations Resolutions, adopted and accepted by UN in 1945. Therefore, all so called “palestinians” must be relocated there. Enough stealing Israel land. Britain and Jordan must compensate Israel for stolen land and natural resources.
Article 24 of the 1964 PLO Charter addressed to UN stipulates: “Palestinian muslims do not exercise authority over West Bank (Judea and Samaria) and Gaza territories”
True History of Fake “palestinians”
The highest ranking Soviet bloc defector, KGB Major General Ion Mihai Pacepa, in his documentary book “Red Horizons” rote:
“The peace process is, and has from the outset, been nothing but a charade. It all started with the creation of a fictitious “Palestinian People” who allegedly demand political self determination. This collective noun was created by the Soviet disinformation masters in 1964 when they created the Palestinian Liberation Organization, the “PLO”. The term “Palestinian People” as a descriptive of Arabs in Palestine appeared for the first time in the preamble of the 1964 PLO Charter, drafted in Moscow. The Charter was affirmed by the first 422 members of the Palestinian National Council, handpicked by the KGB.
Confessions:
Hamas foreign minister Hamad made a shocking statement. (Watch video clip at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jauVARIz8ZM). In his statement, Hamad undermines the fundamental “palestinian identity”: “Praise be to Allah, we all have Arabic roots, every palestinian in Gaza and the West Bank can boast of ancestors from Saudi Arabia, Yemen, or from somewhere else. We are all related by blood. I tell about myself. I am half Egyptian. In Gaza, 30 clans with the surname Al-Masri (Egyptian) live. Brothers! Half palestinians are Egyptians, the other half – Saudis! Who are Palestinians? These are people whose ancestors migrated here from Cairo, Alexandria, Aswan, in Upper Egypt. We are all Egyptians! We all Muslims! We are a part of you!
Arab leaders like Auni Bey Abdul-Hadi told the Peel Commission in 1937: “There is no such country as ‘Palestine’; ‘Palestine’ is a term the Zionists invented!”
In 1946, Arab historian Philip Hitti testified before the Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry that “there is no such thing as Palestine in history.”
In 1977, an executive committee member of the PLO Zahir Muhsein confirmed that there is no such thing as a separate “palestinian” people of Arab descent. In an interview with the Dutch newspaper Trouw in March 31, 1977, he stated the following: “The palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity.”
TEHRAN WANTS BAKU BACK
http://www.wnd.com/2013/04/tehran-wants-baku-back/
I see a possible Iran destabilization plan emerging: external and internal kurds, Azeris; sunnis, and internal dissidents;
I think the plan may be to weaken syria and hezbullah first, hamas has already been weaned off Iran and put under Qatar Egypt{this reduces blowback on Israel and increases GCC hegemony. Will the jihadis in syria focus next on hezbullah and then Iran or will they turn on Israel. If they focus to Hezbullah instead of Israel this indicates to me that there has been a long term grand deal in place that has been evolving whereby everyone gets something they want or need. “Everyone” includes US/GCC/Saudi/Qatar/Egypt/Turkey/Kurds/Israel/Jordan/PA/gaza
Iran on one side, Qatar and SA on the other meet in Syria.
Let them fight as long as possible.
Stalemate in the Syrian Civil War
Israel’s future moves will be highly influenced by regional developments… It makes little sense to discount what’s happening around us.
Besides Syria and lebanon, Iraq there is EGYPT:
SPENGLER
When hunger came to Egypt
By Spengler
@ dove:
That is how U best undermine IL & Zionists!
The war on the Jews continues unabated until IL & the Zionists decide that enough is enough.
UNRWA must be dismantled. A fabrication of the West, that has lasted too long, to antagonize IL and Zionists.
There will never be an end to the Sunni-Shia conflict. That should help IL move forward.
Report: Israel, UAE, Saudis in huge US arms deal
According to the Times, Israel would be permitted to purchase from American contractors the KC-135 refueling tanker planes, “anti-radiation” missiles that target air-defense radars, new advanced radars for jets and the V-22 Osprey aircraft.
The deal also reportedly will include $3 billion dollars in military aid to Israel this fiscal year.
The sale of the V-22 Osprey will be the first to any foreign military, according to the report.
Bell Boeing V-22 Osprey
Column One: Israel: The happy little country
By CAROLINE B. GLICK
Netanyahu thought a moment and said, “I’d like to be remembered as the leader who preserved Israel’s security.”
Canadian Otter says
Then fight them
Form Alliance with Assad
add some context: Kerry’s ‘deadline’ is the price for the Gulf monarchs to take on Iran, but only if Israel swallows the 2002 Saudi Plan first.
Two years is about right. At the rate the State Department is pushing for relocating “palestinian refugees”, the second state will be in the USA.
PICTURES and story of an orphaned baby elephant. She was found last year dragging herself along by her front legs after suffering severe axe wounds inflicted by poachers. She was helped and now she is walking and playing again.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2311547/Orphaned-baby-elephant-nearly-hacked-death-left-paralysed-ivory-poachers-walks-thanks-special-boot.html
I see it as a veiled threat.
Didn’t US general Dayton give Israel a deadline back in 2009? Partition or else? After all the US has been training and arming a Nazi militia in the PA.
“US Lt.-Gen. Keith Dayton, who is responsible for training Palestinian military forces in Jordan, indicated that if Israel does not surrender Judea and Samaria within two years, the Palestinian forces he and his fellow American officers are now training at a cost of more than $300 million could begin killing Israelis.”
– http://israelmatzav.blogspot.ca/2009/05/us-believes-palestinian-police-will.html
The fact that Dayton’s threat was issued at all is something not to be forgotten. Particularly since, as we have seen in the past couple of years, the US has been actively engaged in encouraging and arming MB revolts all over the Middle East.
I still don’t understand why they really believe that a two state solution is the answer. How much more evidence do they need to reveal the real agenda?
Not according to Field Marshall Goebbels! (yemach shimo!)
And Obama has term limits and Bibi does not!