New Right leader says those who are overly stringent on performing Jewish conversion ‘are causing massive damage to Israel and Judaism, blames ‘haredi’ Chief Rabbinate for the problem.
New Right leader Naftali Bennett has promised to pass a law allowing municipal chief rabbis the ability to conduct Jewish conversions as a way of solving what he described as a “time bomb” of Jewish intermarriage in Israel.
The conversion issue is notably the flagship concern of former Shas MK Rabbi Haim Amsalem,
who is number two on the electoral list of the Zehut Party with whom Bennett would like to unite his New Right Party.
In a Facebook post he wrote over the weekend, Bennett noted the large number of Israeli citizens from the former Soviet Union who are integrated into Jewish society, are the descendants of Jews and who marry Israeli Jews, but are not Jewish according to Jewish law.
This problem of potential Jewish intermarriage has concerned the national-religious community, for the most part, since the status of large waves of Russian Jews, who began immigrating to Israel from the former Soviet Union (FSU) in the early 1990s after the collapse of the Iron Curtain, has remained unresolved.
In his Facebook post on Friday, Bennett highlighted the issue and blamed it on the Chief Rabbinate, which he said had been in “haredi [ultra-Orthodox] hands for many years,” for having curtailed the ability of municipal chief rabbis to perform conversions and for making conversion stricter and the process less welcoming.
The former education minister said he would solve it by passing legislation in the next government, should he be elected, which would restore the right of municipal chief rabbis to convene conversion courts themselves – something he said would lead to less stringent demands and a friendlier approach to conversion which, he claimed, would raise the number of conversions every year from around 2,000 to 10,000.
“We have a severe problem, a time bomb, of half a million Israelis who live as Jews exactly like us, feel Jewish, serve in [IDF] combat units, but are however not Jewish according to Jewish law, and are therefore not Jewish,” wrote Bennett.
He also made some sweeping statements, such as that the non-Jewish immigrants and their children from the FSU “want and are willing to accept upon themselves everything required in accordance with Jewish law in order to convert and become Jews.” He added that “the Chief Rabbinate, which is today in haredi hands, simply does allow them to convert in accordance with Jewish law.”Bennett also insisted on a liberal interpretation of the requirements of a convert, asserting that “the most important thing in conversion is the desire to join the Jewish people and be a part of our joint fate,” a definition which does not discuss the requirement to accept the “yoke of Jewish law.”
He concluded that, “‘Stringency’ on conversions is boosting intermarriage. Those who are supposedly strict are causing massive damage to the Jewish people.”
Bennett’s proposal to allow municipal city rabbis to convert actually stems from legislation proposed by MK Elazar Stern in 2013 during the course of the 33rd government, which did not include haredi parties, backed by liberal-leaning national-religious rabbis and organizations.
The legislation advanced to the cusp of final approval by the Knesset, but following intense pressure from the Chief Rabbinate, the haredi parties and hardline, conservative elements in the national-religious community, the MK agreed to pass the measure simply as a cabinet resolution and not legislation.
At the beginning of the last government, the haredi parties as well as hardline rabbinical leaders from the national-religious community forced through a change to the resolution, which gave the Chief Rabbinate authority over which municipal chief rabbis could form conversion courts, essentially giving the body a veto over liberal-minded rabbis who want to increase conversions to solve the intermarriage problem.
Bennett and his ally Ayelet Shaked voted against the motion in the cabinet, but did not attempt to halt it politically.
Bennett said in his Facebook post that in the next government he would promote the measure through full legislation which cannot be changed or annulled by a simple cabinet decision.
The former education minister said he would solve it by passing legislation in the next government, should he be elected, which would restore the right of municipal chief rabbis to convene conversion courts themselves – something he said would lead to less stringent demands and a friendlier approach to conversion which, he claimed, would raise the number of conversions every year from around 2,000 to 10,000.
“We have a severe problem, a time bomb, of half a million Israelis who live as Jews exactly like us, feel Jewish, serve in [IDF] combat units, but are however not Jewish according to Jewish law, and are therefore not Jewish,” wrote Bennett.
He also made some sweeping statements, such as that the non-Jewish immigrants and their children from the FSU “want and are willing to accept upon themselves everything required in accordance with Jewish law in order to convert and become Jews.” He added that “the Chief Rabbinate, which is today in haredi hands, simply does allow them to convert in accordance with Jewish law.”
Bennett also insisted on a liberal interpretation of the requirements of a convert, asserting that “the most important thing in conversion is the desire to join the Jewish people and be a part of our joint fate,” a definition which does not discuss the requirement to accept the “yoke of Jewish law.”
He concluded that, “‘Stringency’ on conversions is boosting intermarriage. Those who are supposedly strict are causing massive damage to the Jewish people.”
Bennett’s proposal to allow municipal city rabbis to convert actually stems from legislation proposed by MK Elazar Stern in 2013 during the course of the 33rd government, which did not include haredi parties, backed by liberal-leaning national-religious rabbis and organizations.
The legislation advanced to the cusp of final approval by the Knesset, but following intense pressure from the Chief Rabbinate, the haredi parties and hardline, conservative elements in the national-religious community, the MK agreed to pass the measure simply as a cabinet resolution and not legislation.
At the beginning of the last government, the haredi parties as well as hardline rabbinical leaders from the national-religious community forced through a change to the resolution, which gave the Chief Rabbinate authority over which municipal chief rabbis could form conversion courts, essentially giving the body a veto over liberal-minded rabbis who want to increase conversions to solve the intermarriage problem.
Bennett and his ally Ayelet Shaked voted against the motion in the cabinet, but did not attempt to halt it politically.
Bennett said in his Facebook post that in the next government he would promote the measure through full legislation which cannot be changed or annulled by a simple cabinet decision.
Bennett is 100% on the mark. His solution is pragmatic and meets Orthodox Religious Standards. This would be allow conversions by City Rabbis on basically the religious standard that had been done in the Army by Zionist Rabbis. This also used to happen in Israel in the past. This certainly occurs in Jewish communities around the world. It would stop the craziness of the Rabinut who are hurting the Jewish people and are very misguided.