T. Belman. Saying you want a broad government is one thing but achieving it is another when Gantz and Lapid have said they won’t serve on a Netanyahu led government. Will Lapid or Gantz join such a broad government? I don’t think so and I hope they don’t unless they agree to Israel retaining all of J&S. How can we not have polarization if they don’t agree to destroy illegal Arab construction and Gantz’s gestures. I like Shaked’s use of “Jewish and sovereign state,” We must bury the term ““Jewish and democratic state.”
This new Party will bring Bibi’s majority to about 65 seats, all right wing.
Interior Minister Ayelet Shaked and Communications Minister Yoaz Hendel launch the Zionist Spirit party
Interior Minister Ayelet Shaked’s Yamina Party and Communications Minister Yoaz Hendel’s Derech Eretz Party will run together in the upcoming Knesset election under the new name “Haruach HaTzionit” (The Zionist Spirit), the two announced on Wednesday evening.
The two spoke about the schism in Israeli society and instability of the system, and repeated what many party leaders have already said: What the country needs is a broad, stable government.
“The coming generations will have a hard time understanding how the start-up nation arrived at this situation – political polarization that like a snowball became the number one cause for the political instability in Israel.”
“Every group is fighting a fight to the death in order to delegitimize the other side.”
“The coming election is a critical junction for the state of Israel, as each bloc strives to form a narrow government that will deepen on extreme elements,” she said.
Shaked praised Hendel, calling him a “go-getter” with many accomplishments in the government as Communications Minister.
Shaked’s regrets AND Hendel’s ambitions
She also spoke briefly about the lessons she learned during the past year.
While the former government was necessary at the time, “in hindsight the move did not work and a narrow government cannot create political stability.”
Another lesson was that “Israel cannot depend on an Arab party,” and that “the Zionist enterprise cannot be dependent on votes of representatives of the Arab sector in Israel.”
“Something was missing – and it was a nationalist and Zionist spirit,” Shaked added.
Shaked noticeably did not mention opposition leader Benjamin Netanyahu. She also mentioned the need for a “Jewish and sovereign state,” a noticeable phrase that differed from the oft-used “Jewish and democratic state.”
Hendel in his speech was more direct. He repeated Shaked’s point about the need for stability but added specifics.
“We are determinedly against a narrow government [led] by Netanyahu which will only deal with whatever is good for him. We are determinedly against a left-wing narrow government with the Joint List and extreme elements,” he said.
Each extreme was untenable, Hendel argued, since one side with Otzma Yehudit’s Itamar Ben-Gvir will fire the attorney-general and halt Netanyahu’s trial, while the other will be forced to make concessions to the Joint List or continue on with the election cycle.
“We have had enough,” he said.
“In Israel, there is a statesmanlike Right. We will not be forced to choose between the Center-Left and the ‘only Bibi’ camp.”
“We will force stability,” he stressed.
The only way forward is a unity government between the Likud and the Center-Left, Hendel argued. He did not say whether in such a scenario he would be willing to sit under Netanyahu as prime minister.
Hendel explicitly said that he wants to be the next public security minister to make Israel safer. He also stressed the high cost of living as a priority for the new party.
Fittingly, Shaked and Hendel entered the press conference hall to a song by Shlomi Shabbat, “Only because of the spirit,” and the words, “You, me and God next to me will win, not because of the strength but because of the spirit [or wind] blowing at my back.”
According to the agreement, Hendel will be placed in the number two slot after Shaked and Hauser will occupy the number four slot.
Deputy Religious Affairs Minister Matan Kahana, who is still officially connected to Shaked but had considered running in a different party, was not mentioned and it is unclear whether he will be a part of the party.
Yamina repeatedly did not pass the electoral threshold in polls, but the addition of Hendel and Hauser will likely give her a boost, since the addition of the former New Hope members may attract right-wing voters who opposed New Hope’s merger with Blue and White.
Hendel and Hauser first entered the Knesset in 2020 after the third election of the current cycle as part of the “Telem” faction, which was part of Blue and White.
Telem broke away from Blue and White after its chairman and current Defense Minister Benny Gantz decided to enter into a rotation government with Likud leader and then prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu. In response, Hauser and Hendel, who supported the rotation government, broke away from Telem and formed their own faction – Derech Eretz.
In the March 2021 election Derech Eretz joined Justice Minister Gideon Sa’ar’s New Hope party but did not officially merge with it. The two were inserted in slots four and eight on New Hope’s list. The party won six seats, but three out of the six – Sa’ar, Construction and Housing Minister Ze’ev Elkin and Hendel – quit the Knesset as part of the Norwegian law. Hauser thus entered the Knesset and served as Deputy Speaker.
https://www.jpost.com/israel-elections/article-713446
After reading this article, I commented:
the JPOST is an insightful article. However, an observation: Politician’s do what politicians do, they always start in the middle of the road and never show their complete hand, nor do they state emphatically all their positions. When they do make a claim and then do not fulfill those comments they are considered, to have lied, not fulfilled their promise or so forth. Why? Because they leave themselves wiggle room to change their positions based on the political winds and or a changing environment. Why? I think it is due to their number one job is to stay in power.
I wait and long for the day when Israeli leaders become like their forefathers the prophets and stand their ground to further Hashems position instead of their own political careers. Is that simplistic? yes, it could be. However, I do not get the feeling that they really believe Hashem is in control and all they really get is the chance to make a decision like Pharoah, “let my people go!” or no, keep the people chained so they cannot serve Hashem. Stand with Hashem or stand with which ever party is currently in control.
How fast could Hashem’s program advance if they(we) got on his side instead of working against his program?
“…Although these discrepancies seem insignificant, they may cause voters to avoid voting for Zionist Spirit. Anti-Netanyahu, moderate-Right voters may be put off by Shaked’s rhetoric, while some of her current supporters may be put off by Hendel’s strong sentiments against a fully right-wing government and fear that he will lead the party back into a government similar to the current one.
The mixed messages could offset any gains the two made by merging, and keep them below the electoral threshold, where they have sat since the beginning of July.”
“Both Shaked and Hendel are guilty of breaking promises that they made to their voters, with serious ramifications. ”
https://www.jpost.com/israel-elections/article-713375
Insightful piece.
So, they are willing to enter a government led by Bibi so long as it not “narrow” enough to keep the show trial against him going?
TOI reported yesterday;
I see that stance as problematic.. Are they going to attach to Blue and White and or Lapid so that Bibi is forced to take both of them or none of them.. Bennett and Lapid did that one before..
I have no problem with such a broad coalition providing it backs destroying illegal Arab construction at a minimum..
I would hate for Shaked with her partner Lapid or Ganz being able to threaten the government by voting against it on such a matter. Plus I insist on the Min of Defense being a Likudnik who wants to keep Judea and Samaria.