[…]
But, more importantly, Mitchell (Trump’s bona fide expert on Eastern Europe) underscored, preserving the West cannot happen without a strong and free Europe, which is a vital interest of the United States. And here he did not diplomatically avoid naming names and identifying problems. It is Russia and China who “want to break the West,” he said and EU allies (read Western Europe) who are showing insufficient willingness to “defend their own continent.” He further singled out specific European policies that the U.S. consider counterproductive — the Nord Stream 2 pipeline and the Iran agreement.
The first one is clearly directed against the interests of Eastern Europe and will benefit Russia’s monopolistic gas hegemony and make NATO’s eastern flank more vulnerable. Though Mitchell did not say it, Germany is the clear culprit here, as the above well-documented CEPA study proves. The Iran agreement, which is still supported by the EU even after the U.S. pulled out of it, allowed the expansion of Teheran’s influence to the borders of Israel, the largest such expansion since antiquity, Mitchell noted, and represents a clear danger for the West in Washington’s view.
Mitchell did not dwell on the current background of the alliance’s politics, but there is no doubt that it was a motivating factor for this groundbreaking policy statement. And that background includes the flat-out refusal by Germany to commit to spending 2% of GDP on defense, except in the very distant future, which makes the largest economy in Europe a consumer, rather than a contributor to collective security. Compare this attitude to the enthusiastic support for NATO’s role by nine Eastern European countries (known as the Bucharest 9) which met in Warsaw, as Mitchell was speaking, and endorsed a greater role for the alliance in the East. It is this clear and widening fault line that has prompted numerous pundits to speculate that Trump may be pivoting to the East in Europe, while others have interpreted it as a declaration of war on Russia.
There are other pregnant developments on the old continent that cannot but affect the cohesion of the Atlantic alliance — from Italy’s new Eurosceptic government closing its harbors to migrant vessels to a fundamental and widening conflict over immigration by the two ruling parties, the Christian Democratic Union (CDU), and the Christian Social Union (CSU) in Germany. The CSU, which is Bavaria-based, wants to turn back migrants at the border, while Chancellor Angela Merkel, who is to blame for the migrant debacle, is doing everything possible to avoid that and thus admit that she was wrong all along. It may be a long shot, but a turn to the right in Germany, may be the best news for Trump and NATO yet.
Alex Alexiev is chairman of the Center for Balkan Black Sea Studies (cbbss.org). He could be reached at alexievalex4@gmail.com.
The following are Western results of the recent votes in the UNGA against Israel — and simultaneously, I note, against the US:
Extremely anti-US:
TURKEY
Anti-US:
ALBANIA, ANDORRA, BELGIUM, ESTONIA, FINLAND, FRANCE, GREECE, ICELAND, IRELAND, JAPAN, LIECHTENSTEIN, LUXEMBOURG, MALTA, MONTENEGRO, NEW ZEALAND, NORWAY, PORTUGAL, SLOVENIA, SPAIN, SWEDEN, SWITZERLAND
Neutral:
ROMANIA, AUSTRIA, BULGARIA, CANADA, CROATIA, CYPRUS, CZECHIA, DENMARK, GERMANY, HUNGARY, ITALY, LATVIA, LITHUANIA, NETHERLANDS, POLAND, S. KOREA, SAN MARINO, SLOVAKIA, N. MACEDONIA, UK BRITAIN
Pro-US:
AUSTRALIA, ISRAEL, US AMERICA
That shows a definite East-West split. An even starker East-West split is shown, in acceptance of homosexuality:
http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2013/12/12/eastern-and-western-europe-divided-over-gay-marriage-homosexuality/
Favoring:
NORWAY, SWEDEN, DENMARK, UK, IRELAND, NETHERLANDS, BELGIUM, FRANCE, SPAIN, SWITZERLAND, GERMANY
Split:
FINLAND, CZECHIA
Against:
PORTUGAL, GREECE, BULGARIA, SLOVENIA, HUNGARY, SLOVAKIA, POLAND, ESTONIA, LITHUANIA, CROATIA
According to other sources, the US lines up with W. Europe on the above matter, and Romania with E. Europe. I picked these sources, because the data was readily available, and showed a statistically significant distinction between the two groups. Combining the two, one might see a quick-and-dirty East-West map:
West:
NORWAY, SWEDEN, IRELAND, BELGIUM, FRANCE, SPAIN, SWITZERLAND, FINLAND, AUSTRIA, GERMANY,
Divided:
(USA*), PORTUGAL, GREECE, SLOVENIA, ESTONIA*, CZECHIA
*Estonia and the US are divided in opposite ways to each other
Eastern:
BULGARIA, HUNGARY, SLOVAKIA, POLAND, LITHUANIA, CROATIA, (ROMANIA)
As a rough approximation, Europe is divided between the former Warsaw Pact allies, on the one hand, and America’s traditional allies on the other. On some social issues, such as homosexuality, we seem to be closer to Western Europe; but on some political issues, such as acceptance of Israel, we seem closer to Eastern Europe.