T. Belman. I agree with all points made by Mandel but more could have been said. First of all I do not believe Trump is even considering withdrawal from Syria. His remarks were just a head-fake. Secondly the issue facing the alliance of the US, Saudi Arabia and Israel is not to avoid war but to initiate it on their terms. All three are committed to stopping Iran from getting the bomb. To do this, they must pre-empt. Also, I believe that they will encourage regime change. There is little doubt that all the threats you mentioned will work together to bring Israel down. They hope.
Iran, Turkey, Hezbollah, Hamas and the PA are motivated to stop Trump and his plans. They want to undermine his recognition of Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and to prevent the moving of the American Embassy. Plus they want to kill Trump’s expected peace plan. They cannot afford to have Trump calling the shots. They all want the destruction of Israel and they are backed by the NWO including the UN and the EU.
Today there are upwards of 150,000 missiles in Hezbollah’s arsenal, enough to overwhelm every layer of Israel’s missile shield, capable of targeting any location in Israel.
Since the State of Israel was created 70 years ago, the question has always been not if there would be a war, but when. The only question now is will it be in the north against Iran and its proxies Hezbollah, Syrian President Bashar Assad and the Shi’ite Popular Mobilization Units, or will it be in the south against Hamas and Islamic Jihad, or will it originate from over the Green Line among the Arab Palestinians of the West Bank?
Ronen Bergman in The New York Times wrote, “Israel has been asking Russia to guarantee that the Iranians will leave Syria once the war is over. Those requests have been met with indifference… Russia wants to build a secure foothold in the Middle East and its policy requires it to maintain good relations with Iran…if anyone was not yet aware of it, Russia is the dominant power in the region.”
The downing of both the Iranian drone in Israeli airspace and an Israeli fighter jet in February brought all the adversaries to the brink of war. Russia, the new sheriff in town, ordered Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to stand down, and knowing he was alone, he did.
Simon Tisdall opined in The Guardian, “if Iran refuses to leave Syria and continues to expand its military presence…and if Israel continues its cross-border raids, something big, sooner or later, is going to blow.”
A few years ago I spoke to one of the senior international medical personal stationed in Lebanon caring for Syrian refugees. He told me that in every one of the 300 villages he visited in Hezbollah- controlled southern Lebanon missiles were hidden in people’s homes.
Today there are upwards of 150,000 missiles in Hezbollah’s arsenal, enough to overwhelm every layer of Israel’s missile shield, capable of targeting any location in Israel.
To the south, Hamas in Gaza is now feeling like a cornered rat, with no way out. The economic situation is worsening as the Palestinian Authority tightens the noose around their neck. The PA allows Gazans only four hours a day of electricity, while Gaza is an inferno always waiting to explode, fertile ground for radicalization and recruitment to terrorism, with an unemployment rate nearing 50%.
Four years ago Hamas was in a similar economic position, and it choose war as a way to get the attention of the international community. Expect Hamas to have learned from its past three wars with Israel, becoming a more lethal enemy. Israel does not want to take over Gaza, becoming responsible for its services, and it fears that if it overthrows Hamas, an even worse entity may emerge, or uncontrollable chaos.
Last week Hamas did a test run of its newest weapon, mass protests on the border, sending human probes to the security fence, hoping they would be killed and elicit the usual Pavlovian denunciations from anti-Israel groups like Human Rights Watch (HRW), who condemn Israel first and ask questions later. HRW choose not to mention that Hamas even sent a seven-year-old child as bait to cross the border, breaking all international standards. This ongoing test-run may be the starting point for a summer of violence and war.
In Judea and Samaria, PA President Mahmoud Abbas is still trying to show he can be as anti-Israel as Hamas, while the battle to succeed him has already begun. He wants to be remembered as leader of a resistance that did not make peace with the Jews. The rogues’ gallery of would-be successors, from intelligence chief Majid Faraj to former security chiefs Jibril Rajoub and Mohammed Dahlan, to deputy Fatah chairman Mahmoud Aloul, may also decide that agitation and violence this summer may give them the upper hand.
So will there be a war this summer? Nobody knows. But the possibility of a coordinated war aligning Hezbollah, Hamas and Iran, all acting in concert, would present Israel with unprecedented challenges. Israel must be prepared for the next war to break out at any time, and even with the best intelligence, events can spiral out of control, even if none of the adversaries are prepared for an all-out war.
The best way to decrease the chance for war in the Levant this summer is for Trump’s new team of John Bolton and Mike Pompeo to convince him that it is in American interests to remain in Syria for the immediate future, and be resolute that Iran cannot remain in Syria after the civil war ends.
Saudis were to have paid USA $4 billion for having troops in Syria and have not paid a cent. Trump is leveraging talk of pulling out to get Saudis to pay the 4 billion plus more.
The other very likely answer is that Trump has for years talked about that he does not believe the USA should be in these middle east wars. He has been talked into staying a little bit longer. He says other countries need to step up and replace what the USA is doing. The French are reported to already have people on the ground in the USA bases in Syria (including aircraft).
Few if any people, pundits or experts agree with him. When he argued that the job with ISIS is almost done, he made no mention that the job with Iraqn is done because it isn’t. I don’t believe he is giving up the fight against them.
As to why he would do a head fake, he does that a lot to throw people off balance. Another example of deceptive policy is to suggests that a ME peace plan is coming. It isn’t at least not with regard to anything resembling what has been leaked.
There is only one possibility that he would withdraw from Syria and that is if he has already cut a deal with Syria and Russia in which they have agreed to oust Iran and protect Kurdish autonomy in the east in exchange for the US leaving too.
There was much talk about ousting Iran a month ago and now no one talks about it. Israel has also been silent on Trump’s stated intention.
So what go enjoy the beaches, the food, later in the summer fast train to Jerusalem, some good rockin happening . What concert at masada? What’s happening in Jerusalem? Another light show. Maybe T B will take you for shawarma and coffee.
@ Bear Klein:
Perhaps it isn’t a “head-fake”, and Trump is serious. But that only means that as soon as he sees that he made a mistake, he’ll rectify it at once. Perhaps a good healthy chat with Netanyahu and Bolton will change his mind for him.
After all, not only has he sworn undying love for Israel over and over, but he has “put his money where his mouth is” on many an occasion, as did his father before him. donating heavily to Israel and to Jewish Charities in general. They both seemed to always have a particular affinity for Israel and Jews, and were not overly religious as Christians.
I know he’s not going to get US troops killed to save the IDF from having to do the same, but he’s sure to know that just the presence of 5-7,000 US troops, with all the implicit and explicit back-up they’d have, would be enough to deter Iran, Russia and Turkey, even if they were combined on the same intended path
Ted, What would the head fake accomplish? What purpose does it serve?
I think Trump has got Marcron to get French soldiers to replace the USA soldiers. If you are correct and Debka is correct then Trump would have been buying time for US reinforcements to hold off the Turks.
I think I answered my question to you but since I do not trust Debka I am not really convinced this is what is going on.