T. Belman. This article was sent to the the Obama Administration by Lt. Col Howard who also cc’d me. I wrote back as follows:
“The Saudi Peace Initiative should not be the basis for such a peace.
This will be accomplished by a population transfer of at least 2 million Arabs from Gaza and the West Bank to Jordan.
Jordan, of course would require considerable help to resettle these Arabs and to stabilize the country.
Anything short of such a solution would be a half measure and would maintain the conflict.”
The basis should be the original British idea when they were creating Jordan, that Jordan should be the Arab state and Palestine the Jewish state.
At a British conference in Cairo in the spring of 1921, it was envisioned:
“… establishing a Jewish National Home in Palestine west of the Jordan and a separate Arab entity in Palestine east of the Jordan. Abdullah, if installed in authority in Transjordan, could preside over the creation of such an Arab entity.”
Anwar Eshki, a retired major general in the Saudi armed forces, has made it his personal goal to strike peace between Saudi Arabia and Israel, the Wall Street Journal reported on Friday.
A former top adviser to the Saudi government, Eshki raised eyebrows in June when he appeared alongside Israeli Foreign Ministry Director-General and longtime confidant of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu Dore Gold at a conference held by the Council on Foreign Relations in Washington DC, espousing desires to build a Saudi-Israel peace, especially to counter the regionally destabilizing expansion of Iran.
“The main project between me and Dore Gold is to bring peace between Arab countries and Israel,” said Eshki.
The former general noted that while the initiative is “personal,” Riyadh “knows about the project” and “isn’t against it, because we need peace.”
Eshki said Israeli and Saudi plans for their shared principal enemy Iran do not completely align, especially regarding an Israeli strike against Iran. He added, however, that Israel would be interested in dealing first with the threat posed by Iran’s proxy in Lebanon and Syria, Hezbollah, before committing its military to countering the much larger and imposing threat of Iran.
Saudi Arabia is also fighting an Iranian-backed group in Yemen, the Houthi rebels, who have taken over the Yemeni capital of Sana’a, and Eshki said it was the common threat of Iranian attempts to destabilize the region and “revive the Persian Empire” that has brought him and Gold together.
Israeli and Saudi officials have reportedly held several meetings in light of the P5+1 arrangement with Iran to peel back international sanctions in exchange for some restrictions on and monitoring of its nuclear program, which Jerusalem and Riyadh view as a boon to Iranian efforts to spread its influence in the Middle East.
Eshki means of course taqiyya.
There can never be peace between Saudi Arabia and Israel because:
1) Saudi Arabia is a thoroughly Islamic country based on the Koran;
2) The Koran commands Moslems to make war against the Jews and subjugate them to Islamic rule.
Therefore, the only way for Saudi Arabia to make peace with Israel is to renounce the sacred anti-Semitic doctrines which their god and their prophet require them to obey. Good luck with that!